reviewer comments on thesis

Reviewers' Comments to the Authors: Reviewer 1 . There are numerous strengths to this study, including its diverse sample and wellinformed hypotheses.- Author response: Thank you! 1. Comment from Reviewer 1 noting a mistake or oversight in the manuscript. Author response: Thank you for pointing this out. The reviewer is correct, and we have ...

Reviewer Comments to Author(s): Reviewer #1 (Jillon Vander Wal, PhD): Overall, this is a clear, concise, and well-written manuscript. The introduction is relevant and theory based. Sufficient information about the previous study findings is presented for readers to follow the present study rationale and procedures.

improve the work and address their concerns as per the specific comments below. As noted by the Reviewer, the authors feel that the length restraint of a Brief Communication prohibits the inclusion

Make revisions to your manuscript based off reviewer comments; Reply to the reviewers, telling them the changes you’ve made and potentially changes you’ve not made in instances where you disagree with them. Read on to see some example peer review comments and how I replied!

Reviewers will usually have to make general comments on how the paper is written and its subject matter, and this will often include elements of praise. Make sure you acknowledge this: it’ll get them more on your side.

When you write a peer review for a manuscript, what should you include in your comments? What should you leave out? And how should the review be formatted? This guide provides quick tips for writing and organizing your reviewer report. Review Outline. Use an outline for your reviewer report so it’s easy for the editors and author to follow.

Responding to peer reviewer comments can often be stressful, particularly when the comments are exhaustive. This document contains templates to help you respond to reviewer comments. Choose the one that works best for you.

These comments, whether from your dissertation committee or peer reviewers, are a fundamental part of the academic process. They can feel like a mix of praise and criticism, and how you approach them can significantly impact the final quality of your work.

Comment location: Where the reviewer inserted a comment asking for a clarification or a response. I usually make sure that my first column clarifies exactly where the coment is exactly located e.g. “first paragraph, line 3, page 44.”

Here we present ideas and hints that will help both ESL researchers and new researchers understand how this process works and provide guidance that will hopefully make the task of responding to reviewer comments less stressful.